Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Hail Mary's. We'd love to have your feedback!

Don't remember the name of your dish? Find it on our menu!

By submitting, you agree to our , and .

Our Latest Reviews

Wendy 1 day ago

Brussel Sprouts

Great people, owners and food! A must! Support local businesses! Hail yes!

Ttoth 8 days ago

Spicy Apricot Wings

My family and I have had many items on the menu. All have been great, the spicy apricot wings are by far my favorite. Flat fries are great, as are the burgers, pizza, and wraps. Service is spectacular! I've worked in restaurants in the past and am impressed with the service all around. Tom T.

Rebecca 10 days ago

The Barn Burner

The Barn Burner is awesome! The arugula and the balsamic glaze really make this pizza. You definitely won't be disappointed with this pizza!

Melissa 17 days ago

Art's Famous Pimento Cheese Spread

Totally delicious!!

Mary about 1 month ago

Parmesan Tater Tots

Really, really god!

Greco310 about 2 months ago

Antipasto Salad

Awesome food!

Ronald about 2 months ago

The Gong Show

Thanks great service and excellent food, will definitely order from you again.

Angela about 2 months ago

Chili Garlic Wings


Tbiller19 2 months ago

Brussel Sprouts

Fabulous! I get them every time we dine in.

Kenantos 2 months ago

Create Your Own 12" Pizza

This is our favorite and the staff graciously honors our request for sauteed peppers on top of their home made sausage. Just delicious with a salad. Only the best from Hail Mary's.

Christy 2 months ago

Brussel Sprouts

Best Brussel Sprouts EVER😍

Dannicastro4 3 months ago

Old School Italian

Dressing is great. Just like mom used to make. Great staff and atmosphere

Mmaline12 3 months ago

Baked French Onion Dip

We LOVED trying this and will absolutely be back. We also had wings and they were cooked to perfection! We had Sarah as our bartender and she is amazing! We can't wait until our next visit!

Ceciliawalker003 5 months ago

The Goalie

Crispy crust, gooey cheese, and tons of pepperoni: doesn't get much better than that, especially when Bumbleberry is on tap too

C 6 months ago

Baked French Onion Dip

This app is killer - if you like the soup, you'll love this cheesy dip!

Brett 6 months ago

Chili Garlic

These wings were AWESOME. Huge and the sauce was delish.

Kelly 7 months ago

Loaded Flat Fries

Best loaded fries I have ever had. I was almost tempted to get a 2nd order.

86rdbike 8 months ago

Cheesy Garlic Knot

my coworkers and I from SJMC up the street stopped in after work and had one of the best times, your service was perfect and the food and drinks were great.

Katie10lang 8 months ago

Brussel Sprouts

The Brussel sprouts are amazing!! A must have and even my kids like them!!

Marlo 9 months ago

The Goalie

My husband and I love going here! Service is always outstanding and all of the food is delish. Great patio for the summer time and nice and cozy inside.

Eric 2 days ago

Create Your Own 12" Pizza

Hail Mary's pizza is just fantastic. The fresh made dough is the foundation for the fresh made sauces and incredible toppings. Get one today you won't be disappointed.

Brian 8 days ago

Sticky Garlic Wings

Great wings. We decided to try Hail Mary's during the pandemic and have been back several times. Wings and tots are superb!

William 17 days ago

Brussel Sprouts

Amazingly good

Shaune about 1 month ago

Half Pound Cheese Burger

Best Burger in Cleveland!

Cleveburg1 about 2 months ago

Brussel Sprouts

I come back time and time again for the brussel sprouts. These are just about the best I've ever had!

Dwdunn about 2 months ago

Create Your Own 12" Pizza

Everything on the menu is excellent. I have been a patron from the day they opened. Like a fine wine, they only get better! Great place

Rosannemarek about 2 months ago

Basket of Flat Fries

I had the fried perch dinner and I must say it was the best that I have ever had. 4 pieces of perch deep fried, nicely salted flat fries, 3 delicious hush puppies and the best homemade macaroni salad ( small portion-tease)I have had and a slice of fresh lemon. Excellent meal! Best kept secret in Westlake!

Deannamturton 2 months ago

Classic Buffalo Wings

The wings from Hail Marys are the best! Great size, delicious sauce and crispy!

Guest 2 months ago

Spicy Apricot Wings

AMAZING! Love them

Rivconcc 2 months ago

Baked French Onion Dip

Too many dishes to name and I loved them all.... I am in Cleveland two to three times a year for business and NEVER miss going here. The food is great, wait staff perfect and the owner friendly... how much more can you expect? AND...they added an amazing top the outside area!

Cain 2 months ago

The Five Hole

This may be my new favorite pizza! It is the perfect combination of veggies amd cheese!

Jgibbons442 3 months ago


I absolutely love the Vietnamese wings! Whether you dine in or order take out they are simply amazing!

Lumsden24 3 months ago

3 Cheese Perogies

My friends and I had lunch. 2 of them had the pierogi's, we all shared the the flat fries, and 2 of us shared the breakaway pizza. All of us of loved the food. The atmosphere is very relaxing and our service was top notch. We all plan on going back. I highly recommend Hail Mary's! Do yourself a favor and try it.

Audrey 5 months ago

Baked French Onion Dip

I recently discovered this place last year and it is by far my favorite local dining spot. If you are looking for cozy atmosphere paired with delicious home cooked food this is your place. It is a place where everyone knows your name.

Tpasadyn 6 months ago

The Goon

A hidden gem - every menu item I've ordered has been very good. Good beer selection and excellent staff.

Abrzezinski12 7 months ago

Art's Famous Pimento Cheese Spread

Honestly, who could have thought Pimento cheese could be this good. The bread that its served with is so fresh and soft and the cheese has the perfect amount of bite. A great starter for the group or something to snack on with drinks at the bar. Highly recommend. Side note: Brendan and Meghan took great care of us during our visit. Love to see it when bartenders work as a team instead of "my customer vs your customer"

Kiktavy 8 months ago

Brussel Sprouts

Absolutely delicious! I've recommended these to many friends. All have enjoyed! Great serving size and flavor!

Katie10lang 8 months ago

Sticky Garlic

Great wings- little sweet and little spicy - but not too much either!

Kathykaserman 8 months ago


Awesome flavor and large wings. Will definitely b back.. yum!

Kathigreco 10 months ago

Angry Chili

I cannot even describe how delicious these are. I've tried a couple different other flavors also and just awesome! But the Angry Chili are to die for. I also ordered a catering for a my Caregivers Support group and everything was perfect and ready for me when I got there. The group loved everything! Go have a meal you won't be disappointed!❤️


May 2020:
Coming Soon

April 2020:
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery 
Thousand Oaks, CA

March 2020:
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD

February 2020:
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Riverside, CA

January 2020:
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Florence, SC

December 2019:
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Jacksonville, FL

November 2019:
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Seattle, WA

October 2019:
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Portland, OR

September 2019:
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA

August 2019:
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Columbus, GA

July 2019:
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Buffalo, NY

June 2019:
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA

May 2019:
Karen, This Little Pig
Amherst, NY

April 2019:
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria
Atlanta, GA